Press "Enter" to skip to content

Crucial moments from Day 1 of This question and Response phase in Trump’s Senate trial

House impeachment managers and President Donald Trump’s defense staff faced questions from senators on Wednesday since Trump’s Senate trial entered a fresh phase.

The first question, by the three Republicans that are likely to vote to keep the trial with witnesses, might have been the pivotal.

Following is a peek at a few of the finest — and most important — minutes from Wednesday’s question and answer session.

Collins’ query gets at witness problem
Right off the bat, Chief Justice John Roberts browse the White House attorneys a query from Sens. Susan Collins of Maine, presented on behalf of himself, Lisa Murkowski of Alaska and Mitt Romney of Utah.

“If President Trump had more than 1 reason for his alleged behavior, like the pursuit of private political benefit, rooting out corruption and the promotion of domestic interests, the way should the Senate believe more than 1 rationale in its evaluation of Article One?” The query stated, speaking to this first article of impeachment against Trump for misuse of power.

“When you are into mixed rational land, it is apparent that their situation fails. There can not possibly be an impeachable crime whatsoever,” he explained, noting it would be impossible to understand how much every variable weighed in Trump’s mind.

If senators have”any queries regarding whether it had been the variable or a variable,” they ought to call former national security advisor John Bolton to testify about a conversation he had with the president on the topic.

Dershowitz’s debate about national interest
Reacting to a question from Sen. Ted Cruz about if quid pro quos are frequently utilized in foreign policy, Trump attorney Alan Dershowitz indicated there could have been nothing incorrect together with the president looking for foreign aid for his re-election.

That is because a president may think his re-election is the nation’s best interest. “When a president does something that he thinks will help him get elected in the general public interest that cannot be the sort of quid pro quo that ends in impeachment,” Dershowitz said.

Schiff stated the Senate adopting that stance could give”carte blanche” to get more foreign interference later on.

Executive privilege
Republicans asked two questions concerning why House supervisors never hunted legal struggles to White House claims of executive privilege.

“What the president did increase was that this idea of blanket defiance,” Jeffries said, ordering executive branch employees to not cooperate or turn over files to the House impeachment question.

Philbin provided another explanation. “The reason there wasn’t any effort is the House Democrats were only in a rush,” he explained.

House managers used a number of the replies to assert that the senators must telephone Bolton to testify in the aftermath of a bombshell New York Times story he discussed the suspended aid together with the president.

Sen. Tom Carper, a Democrat from Delaware, subsequently requested the House managers, “Is not it true that depositions of those three witnesses at the Clinton trial were performed in just 1 day each? And it is not it true that the Chief Justice as presiding officer in this trial can solve any claims of urgency or other witness problems with no delay.”

“Mr. Chief Justice, the solution is yes,” Jeffries responded.

Philbin countered that testimony out of Bolton would result in a protracted fight over executive privilege.