Press "Enter" to skip to content

Is flight-shaming helping resurrect Europe’s overnight trains?

Three decades ago western Europe’s iconic nighttime trains were chugging into a block, jaded by funding airlines and raised prices.

It is the most recent piece from the expanding nighttime community of the Austrian state railroad company ÖBB, that obtained something of a bet in 2016.

Bernhard Rieder, a spokesman for ÖBB, advised Euronews the firm decided to continue with its nighttime trains in a time when agencies throughout western Europe were shunted into sidings.

It’s a danger that’s paying off, Rieder claims.

“When we speak to people we get the comments that we think more about that way of transportation they’re using,” said Rieder.

“Nowadays you can fly from each stage in Europe to a different one, but they’re currently assessing if there are choices.

“If there are choices, individuals are utilizing them. For us, the most essential issue would be to bring this deal to individuals.”

Even though this is only 1 train company, there are indications of a trend emerging in different areas of Europe.

There’s a similar tendency in Germany.

There’s not any proof that this reduction is only down to individuals feeling guilty about flying, but experts say it has played a part.

The authorities in Stockholm is looking at how to promote more nighttime train services and can be considering Malmo-to-Cologne among the initial destinations.

Why were nighttime trains reduce in the first location?

Back On Track, a motion aimed at fostering pan-European railroad solutions, says a lot of it’s down to EU legislation.

Brussels reported the same company couldn’t own railroad infrastructure such as the paths and run the trains, in an attempt to finish rail monopolies and promote competition.

The transfer allowed rail infrastructure companies to bill for access to its track.

But critics say it’s frustrated nighttime trains, which offer a low-carbon option to taking a brief flight inside the EU.


Back On Track claims before the laws, if a firm worked with the trains and possessed the trail, placing on a nighttime service did not cost anything additional. However, with the debut of track access fees, it turned into more expensive.

Deutsche Bahn cut its overnight solutions in Germany in 2016, while at France 60 percent were ceased from the years to 2019.

There were national nighttime trains in just 11 EU nations, a 2017 report found, with many more services in eastern and central Europe.

“The economics of a sleeper [train] are harder, and they are those that get pushed over the border now that trains become billed track accessibility,” Mark Smith, the guy behind train booking and information portal The Man In Chair Sixty-One, informed Euronews.

“When the business was vertically integrated, and also the same operator owned the trail and ran the trains, you then understood perfectly well that the trail was there anyhow, if they operate the sleeper train or never.

“So effectively they had been conducting the sleeper train at no price so far as infrastructure had been worried since there’s no rescue if they ceased running the train. Nowadays every train must be charged hefty monitor access charges, such as sleepers.”

The effect of Thunberg as well as also the take-off of flight shaming was associated with a drop in the number of folks utilizing airports in Sweden.

Before this month Swedavia, that works 10 of the nation’s busiest airports, shown that a 4 percent drop in passengers this past year, in comparison with 2018. International travelers fell by 2 percent but people taking national flights by 9 percent.

“I think there is still increased climate flying and awareness will be the most carbon-intensive action everyone can participate in.”

Smith, however, told Euronews the prevalence of trains hadn’t only started with Greta. On the contrary, it’s been a radical increase over numerous decades.

“When I started the site back in 2001, when individuals who employed it gave me a motive for needing to visit Italy or Spain by train, then they’d typically say they have got a phobia of flying, or else they are mutually restricted from flying, or else they understand they especially enjoy train travel.

“And that changed and within the previous six to eight decades, people have begun mentioning two things and it is always the 2 items together. They are fed up with all the airline and airport experience, and they wish to lower their carbon footprint”

Is flying worse than just taking the train?

Back On Track says European long-distance trains are almost always better for the climate about the aircraft, together with the gap greater if they operate on electrified paths and are powered with a low-carbon energy sauce.

A train from Vienna to Brussels generates 35.3pound of CO2, in comparison to 152.8kg by carrying the airplane, based on

“It’s too soon to say if this is a permanent trend because of’flygskam’, or one which is the result of decreasing economic development, changes in earnings, along with other aspects.

“The numbers of those who have publicly vowed not to fly is modest, but we surely accept the’flygskam’ movement exists and we must reach out to anybody worried about aviation’s environmental document so they are given the details and can generate an educated decision about their journey.

“For instance, not lots of men and women are aware that the CO2 of a normal flight has halved since 1990.

“We’re also dedicated to reducing aviation net carbon emissions to half of 2005 levels by 2050, which might be in accord with the general Paris climate arrangement targets.”

What’s holding Europe’s nighttime trains back?

Campaigners have argued for fuel in air travel to be taxed in precisely the same manner it’s in the railroad market. They also wish to make it easy to reserve a train around Europe as possible to book a flight.

“It’s remarkably more costly to do so, and that is to get a whole slew of factors. Not having kerosene taxation plays an important job.

Eurostar is the sole operator on the Channel Tunnel whereas if you would like to fly from London to Paris, I believe you do have many airlines competing on this.”

The railroad industry resides in silos and anxieties about its little piece so that they do not work collectively.

“Night trains are extremely popular with people attempting to go long distances.

“Because high-speed trains are fantastic for 2 -, three- or – four-hour travel times, maybe five. However, whenever you begin getting into six, seven or even eight hours, that is a day gone and you truly wish to leave in the day and sleep on the train. Night trains are an effective manner rail can compete with atmosphere over significantly longer distances compared to which high-speed trains are more aggressive.”

Smith also called on Brussels to look at if excess track access prices are discouraging European operators out of place on trains. “I think that it’s a marketplace failure and that I think the EU has to be involved,” he explained.