Press "Enter" to skip to content

Leaked documents show Facebook leveraged user Information to fight Competitions and Assist friends

Last updated on November 7, 2019

A cache of leaked Facebook files reveals the way the organization’s CEO, Mark Zuckerberg, oversaw programs to merge the social network electricity and control opponents by treating its users’ information as a bargaining chip. The files were obtained and are being printed by NBC News.

This trove comprises roughly 7,000 pages in total, of which approximately 4,000 are inner Facebook communications such as emails, internet chats, notes, spreadsheets, and presentations, mostly from 2011 to 2015. About 1,200 pages have been indicated as”highly confidential”

Taken together, they reveal how Zuckerberg, together with his board and management group, discovered ways to exploit Facebook users’ information — such as information about friends, relationships and photographs — as leverage within the firms it surfaced with. In some instances, Facebook would benefit spouses by giving them preferential access to particular kinds of user information while denying the identical access to rival businesses.

By way of instance, Facebook gave Amazon unique access to consumer data since it had been spending cash on Facebook advertisements. In a different case, the messaging program MessageMe was cut off from access to info since it had grown too popular and may compete with Facebook.

All of the time, Facebook intended to openly framework these motions as a means to safeguard consumer privacy, the files reveal.

Back in October, New York Attorney General Letitia James declared that 47 attorneys general from nations and U.S. lands plan to get involved in a New York-led antitrust research to Facebook.

Along with internal communications, they also comprise depositions from Facebook workers and professional witnesses (elements of that can be lost ) and other court filings. They stay under protective order in the civil litigation called Six4Three v. Facebook.

“As we have mentioned many times, Six4Three — founders of this Pikinis program — cherry-picked these records from years past as part of a litigation to induce Facebook to discuss info on friends of their program’s users,” Paul Grewal, vice president and deputy general counsel at Facebook, said in an announcement published by the business in April. “The collection of files, by design, tells just 1 side of this story and omits significant context. We stand from the stage changes we made from 2014/2015 to stop individuals from sharing their buddies’ data with programmers such as the founders of Bikinis.”

After approached Tuesday for additional comments on the book of these papers, Facebook didn’t respond.

Facebook hasn’t contested the authenticity of the files NBC News obtained.

Zuckerberg’s approach to exert control over the program market throughout the period of time covered by the files triggered one Facebook worker to compare the organization to villains out of”Game of Thrones” and yet another to explain the treatment of external app programmers as”form of unethical” However, Zuckerberg’s strategy also gained admiration: Doug Purdy, afterward Facebook’s manager of merchandise, explained the CEO as a”grasp of leverage,” based on the documents.

The group seems to be exactly like things acquired by the British Parliament in late 2018 as part of a research on Facebook.


The legal case revolves around an all-but-defunct startup called Six4Three, which sued Facebook from 2015 following the firm announced plans to cut off access to some kinds of user information. Six4Three’s program, Bikinis, that soft-launched in 2013, relied upon that information to permit users to readily find Facebook photographs of the buddies in bathing suits.

Six4Three asserts it had been driven out of business once the social networking giant cut off its access to detailed info regarding Facebook users. Years before, Facebook’d stated that outside programs would compete on a”level playing field” using Facebook’s programs, but that understanding finally stopped.

Several other programs besides Six4Three also faded off as a consequence: Lulu, a program that allowed girls to rate the guys they obsolete; an identity fraud-detecting program named Beehive ID; along with also the Swedish breast cancer recognition program Rosa Bandet (Pink Ribbon).

Six4Three’s creator Ted Kramer has signed a sworn statement stating he didn’t leak the records.

“They created a strategy that required repeated violations of this Protective Order in this scenario and the following orders meant to enforce the Protective Order,” Facebook’s attorneys said.

“They implemented this program. The result is shocking: Facebook’s highly confidential data — that Facebook made based on the assumption that the Court will have the ability to enforce its orders whenever they weren’t followed closely — is spread across the globe.”